Close X

Leave a comment


Name:
Email:
Comment:
  I have read and understand the terms and conditions
 

Please click the post button only once - your comment will not be published immediately

Finance and banking

Business Focus >>

The new manufacturers The new manufacturers

A great British renaissance has been taking place. From Aberdeen to the West Country, the zing is back in manufacturing. It’s about time this spectacular story was told.

  • hot
  • hot
  • hot 100

Me FD, you private equity

by Phil Thornton - Wednesday, 26th September 2007 -

I can recall watching a Tarzan film in which the great man is tied down on a beach. Eventually the rising water will bring a shoal of piranhas to inflict a particularly hideous death. It must feel a little like that being an FD.

You are aware that all around you is a rising tide of global cash liquidity that could burst in at any moment in the form of a private equity takeover offer.

Back in the 1980s it seemed relatively straightforward. Private equity – or leveraged buyout as it was then – was the tool for sorting out companies languishing under disinterested management.

But now private equity funds have found it so easy to raise investment in this era of low inflation and low interest rates that they have turned their eye towards companies that have already completed a turnaround.

Sainsbury’s is well on the road to recovery and health group Alliance Boots is only just starting to reap the benefits of its merger. These two deals have a current aggregate price of almost £20bn.

It is breathtaking that a small group of financiers could use debt leverage to launch buyouts on such a scale.

Trade union anger at the fallout from the purchase of motoring organisation the AA from Centrica by private equity firms Permira and CVC has catapulted the issue on to the front page and into the House of Commons. The outcome is a government review of the tax liability of private equity firms.

However, the fact that US private equity group KKR emerged as a potential bidder for Alliance Boots weeks after the GMB grabbed headlines by bringing a camel to protest at Permira head Damon Buffini on his way to church – think of the parable of the rich man and the camel passing through the eye of a needle- – shows demand is still overwhelming.

So what does it mean if private equity comes knocking at your door? There have been claims that it puts workers under pressure and delivers huge profits to investors, and counterclaims that it creates jobs and sculpts more efficient companies. The truth is perhaps somewhere in between.

I would offer five lessons to FDs who find themselves in the eye of the storm. The first is that private equity firms cut jobs and cap wage growth in the aftermath of a takeover.
This means, inevitably, there will be growing pressure on private equity-owned firms to provide financial assistance to redundant workers. Management buyout companies add jobs over the long-term.

Second, wage growth is modest in the first year but grows rapidly through to the sixth year after a buyout due to increased productivity under new ownership. This is worth considering when compiling budgets.

Third, the rewards can be vast – depending of course on which chair you are sitting in. The biggest rewards are for those running the private equity firms and realistic estimates put the sky as the limit on those returns.

The problem, and this is the fourth lesson, is that the existing management would stand to gain a small fortune if they were kept on, which lands them with a conflict of interest.

Their duty as directors is to maximise value for shareholders, which would probably involve putting up some resistance. That will not be popular with the private equity bidder and could jeopardise their position if it wins.

The last and most prosaic lesson is that any takeover offer may fail through shareholder resistance, regulatory problems or political pressure – if you’re big enough. So during this entire maelstrom, FDs have to carry on running their day-to-day business.

BUSINESS NEWS >>

"Don't let the market be your boss"

By Kate Pritchard - October 06, 2008 5:57pm GMT

Serial entrepreneur and investor Maxwell Packe says private equity-backed firms have an edge over publicly listed companies. “They don’t have to meet targets set by teenage scribblers,” he says.

“Why bother with an IPO?” asks Audio Network founder

By Rebecca Burn-Callander - October 06, 2008 3:20pm GMT

Robert Hurst raised £600,000 of seed funding from 40 music composers, sound designers and angels to get his online sound and music portal off the ground. Having organised his own private IPO, he’s suspicious of the traditional listing process.

Five ways to avoid redundancies

By Real Business - October 06, 2008 12:31pm GMT

You’re in a pickle. You desperately need to cut your employee wage bill but you’re reluctant to make redundancies. Fear not. We’ve come up with some alternatives to swinging the scythe.

“Always accept a dinner invitation from an Asian client!”

By Rebecca Burn-Callander - October 03, 2008 5:29pm GMT

Kamel Hothi arrived in the UK when she was six. As a girl raised in a traditional Indian family, she was never supposed to work, pursue higher education, or even make eye contact with men. Yet now she’s director of Asian Markets at Lloyds TSB, opening up opportunities for hundreds of women just like her.

Good growth for Ted Baker

By Catherine Woods - October 03, 2008 10:43am GMT

Ted Baker founder Ray Kelvin says the clothing retailer remains “understandably cautious” about the second half of the year despite posting a 8.2 per cent increase in revenue to £71.6m.


BUSINESS COMMENT >>

Follow the brothel's lead

By Catherine Woods - October 03, 2008 3:58pm GMT

If you’re not an Australian, you may not find the following article as amusing as I have.

Economic downturn headlines

By Catherine Woods - October 02, 2008 2:41pm GMT

There’s more doom and gloom in the news today about the economic downturn.

Deal or no deal

By Kate Pritchard - October 01, 2008 3:43pm GMT

Jon Moulton wasn’t exactly exaggerating when he told us the outlook for the private equity industry was gloomy.

Russell Crowe's big banking idea

By Catherine Woods - October 01, 2008 12:01pm GMT

Russell Crowe tries, and fails, to fix Wall Street.

Eco-preneurs in the US

By Catherine Woods - September 26, 2008 5:14pm GMT

It’s always interesting to hear what’s happening within the entrepreneurial community across the pond and an article published today has revealed the growing eco-preneurial movement within the travel and hospitality sectors.


Click here to sign up for the Real Business newsletter
Real Business Front Cover